Why does this return the same index?

Question

I want to run two different lua string find on the same string " (55)"

Pattern 1 "[^%w_](%d+)", should match any number

Pattern 2 "[%(|%)|%%|%+|%=|%-|%{%|%}|%,|%:|%*|%^]", should match any of these ( ) % + = - { } , : * ^ characters.

Both of these patterns return 2, why? Also if I run a string match, they return ( and 55 respectivly (as expected).

Answer 1

It seems you are using the patterns with string.find that finds the first occurrence of the pattern in the string passed. If an instance of the pattern is found a pair of values representing the start and end of the string is returned. If the pattern cannot be found nil is returned.

Both patterns find a match at Position 2: [^%w_](%d+) finds ( because it is matched with [^%w_] (a char other than letter, digit or _), and [%(|%)|%%|%+|%=|%-|%{%|%}|%,|%:|%*|%^] matches the ( because it is part of the character set.

However, the first pattern can be re-written using a frontier pattern, %f[%w_]%d+, that will match 1+ digits if not preceded with letters, digits or underscore, and the second pattern does not require such heavy escaping, [()%%+={},:*^-] is enough (only % needs escaping here, as the - is placed at the end of the character set and is thus treated as a literal hyphen).

See this Lua demo:

a = " (55)"
for word in string.gmatch(a, "%f[%w_]%d+") do print(word) end
-- 55
for word in string.gmatch(a, "[()%%+={},:*^-]+") do print(word) end
-- (, )