what is better in my case Postgres BDR or Postgres-XL?

1.5k views Asked by At

Currently I am working on making the 2 node cluster of PostgreSQL on bare metal cloud. I am very confused about either which approach should I go.

Like i have one option that is PostgreSQL BDR (bi directional replica). In this approach, I have benefit that my both nodes will have read and write access. but now I came to know about PostgreSQL XL. This approach works on sharding approach. Can anybody tell me or help to that either which approach should I go? Sharding will give me benefit or not? I want my Postgres highly available and fast. Which approach will help me in this regard.

Or any other suggestions that you wanna give me.

One more thing. I want to make my cluster horizontal scalable.

1

There are 1 answers

5
Craig Ringer On

The best solution in most cases is option (c): neither. Use stock PostgreSQL + active/standby failover.

I say that as a BDR developer. It's a great tool (in my opinion) for workloads that need it. But it comes with some considerable costs, like any multi-master system, and should not be used if you don't actually need it.

Most people who think they need multi-master, don't. Or rather, don't understand the impacts and trade-offs.

Read the BDR documentation on multi-master conflicts.