sort graph by distance to end nodes

853 views Asked by At

I have a list of nodes which belong in a graph. The graph is directed and does not contain cycles. Also, some of the nodes are marked as "end" nodes. Every node has a set of input nodes I can use.

The question is the following: How can I sort (ascending) the nodes in the list by the biggest distance to any reachable end node? Here is an example off how the graph could look like. enter image description here

I have already added the calculated distance after which I can sort the nodes (grey). The end nodes have the distance 0 while C, D and G have the distance 1. However, F has the distance of 3 because the approach over D would be shorter (2).

I have made a concept of which I think, the problem would be solved. Here is some pseudo-code:

sortedTable<Node, depth> // used to store nodes and their currently calculated distance
tempTable<Node>// used to store nodes 
currentDepth = 0;

- fill tempTable with end nodes

while( tempTable is not empty)
{

    - create empty newTempTable<Node node>

    // add tempTable to sortedTable
    for (every "node" in tempTable)
    {
        if("node" is in sortedTable)
        {
            - overwrite depth in sortedTable with currentDepth
        }
        else 
        {
            - add (node, currentDepth) to sortedTable
        }

        // get the node in the next layer
        for ( every "newNode" connected to node)
        {
            - add newNode to newTempTable
        }

        - tempTable = newTempTable  
    }
    currentDepth++;
}

This approach should work. However, the problem with this algorithm is that it basicly creates a tree from the graph based from every end node and then corrects old distance-calculations for every depth. For example: G would have the depth 1 (calculatet directly over B), then the depth 3 (calculated over A, D and F) and then depth 4 (calculated over A, C, E and F).

Do you have a better solution to this problem?

1

There are 1 answers

1
amit On BEST ANSWER

It can be done with dynamic programming.

The graph is a DAG, so first do a topological sort on the graph, let the sorted order be v1,v2,v3,...,vn.

Now, set D(v)=0 for all "end node", and from last to first (according to topological order) do:

D(v) = max { D(u) + 1, for each edge (v,u) }

It works because the graph is a DAG, and when done in reversed to the topological order, the values of all D(u) for all outgoing edges (v,u) is already known.


Example on your graph:

Topological sort (one possible):

H,G,B,F,D,E,C,A

Then, the algorithm:

init: 

D(B)=D(A)=0

Go back from last to first:

D(A) - no out edges, done
D(C) = max{D(A) + 1} = max{0+1}=1
D(E) = max{D(C) + 1} = 2
D(D) = max{D(A) + 1} = 1
D(F) = max{D(E)+1, D(D)+1} = max{2+1,1+1} = 3
D(B) = 0
D(G) = max{D(B)+1,D(F)+1} = max{1,4}=4
D(H) = max{D(G) + 1} = 5

As a side note, if the graph is not a DAG, but a general graph, this is a variant of the Longest Path Problem, which is NP-Complete.
Luckily, it does have an efficient solution when our graph is a DAG.