Loop macro: Parentheses in the using subclause

72 views Asked by At

Chapter 22 of Practical Common Lisp explains (among other things) how to use both the keys and the values when iterating through a hash table with the loop macro:

(loop for k being the hash-keys in h using (hash-value v) ...)

The explanation is concluded with the following footnote:

Don't ask me why LOOP's authors chickened out on the no-parentheses style for the using subclause.

That's perfectly fine for the book and I don't blame Peter Seibel for not knowing it. Still, I am somewhat curious about the reasons for this design decision of. Why isn't the syntax something like

(loop for k being the hash-keys in h using hash-value v ...)

Is it easier to parse? Or is there some deeper reason behind it?

0

There are 0 answers