I am using Eigen to do some linear algebra computations in my code. However, all of mathematical formulas are based on the fact that indexing starts from 1. So, each time that I want to implement them in the code, I have to check if my indexing in the code is consistent with them or not. I was wondering that if it is possible to tell Eigen to start the indexing from 1 instead of 0.

2 Answers

dfri On Best Solutions

Indexing operations in Eigen allow, in addition to indexing with integers, indexing with symbolic indices. You should be able implement your own custom symbolic index, derived from Eigen::symbolic::BaseExpr, that could be used as a 1-based index API, where its eval_impl method simply subtracts 1 from its arg. E.g.:

template<typename Arg0>
class MyIndexExpr : public BaseExpr<MyIndexExpr<Arg0> >
  MyIndexExpr(const Arg0& arg0) : m_arg0(arg0) {}

  template<typename T>
  Index eval_impl(const T& values) const { return m_arg0.eval_impl(values) - 1; }
  Arg0 m_arg0;

To use this in product code, however, would most likely be a very bad idea, likely to lead to confusion, possible bugs as well as an extra non-motivated run-time overhead for any indexing. As you are coding in C++, you might want to stick to its zero-based indexing practice. Maybe you could consider symbolic indexing for when writing tests for your formulas, but using integer zero-based indexing for your product code.

chtz On

The answer is "not really".

Of course, as @πάνταῥεῖ suggested, you could write a wrapper or inherit from Eigen types and overwrite the indexing operators accordingly. Alternatively, you could implement a custom Index type which, when converted to Eigen::Index, will subtract 1.

But both approaches are error-prone and will likely rather increase confusion, especially if you miss some relevant parts. Also it will extremely confuse any C++ programmer looking at your code, as 0-based indexing is the most natural way in C/C++ (and many languages whose syntax is derived from them, like Java, C#, ...)

Finally, (as also suggested by @dfri) if you code in C++ get used to 0-based indexing, this will save you a lot of trouble in the long run.