In a project I read, there are two header files and two declarations for the same class. One is used by programs that use this library, serving as an interface. Another is used by the library itself.The interface header file is simpler. It doesn't contain private members and has less methods. Even methods that appear in both files may not appear in the same order. I wonder if it is legal to have 2 header files for the same class? If it is not, what are the possible consequences?
Is it legal to have 2 header files for the same class in c++?
681 views Asked by Tokubara At
1
There are 1 answers
Related Questions in C++
- new thread blocks main thread
- Extracting viewCount & SubscriberCount from YouTube API V3 for a given channel, where channelID does not equal userID
- Display images on Django Template Site
- Difference between list() and dict() with generators
- How can I serialize a numpy array while preserving matrix dimensions?
- Protractor did not run properly when using browser.wait, msg: "Wait timed out after XXXms"
- Why is my program adding int as string (4+7 = 47)?
- store numpy array in mysql
- how to omit the less frequent words from a dictionary in python?
- Update a text file with ( new words+ \n ) after the words is appended into a list
Related Questions in CLASS
- new thread blocks main thread
- Extracting viewCount & SubscriberCount from YouTube API V3 for a given channel, where channelID does not equal userID
- Display images on Django Template Site
- Difference between list() and dict() with generators
- How can I serialize a numpy array while preserving matrix dimensions?
- Protractor did not run properly when using browser.wait, msg: "Wait timed out after XXXms"
- Why is my program adding int as string (4+7 = 47)?
- store numpy array in mysql
- how to omit the less frequent words from a dictionary in python?
- Update a text file with ( new words+ \n ) after the words is appended into a list
Related Questions in HEADER-FILES
- new thread blocks main thread
- Extracting viewCount & SubscriberCount from YouTube API V3 for a given channel, where channelID does not equal userID
- Display images on Django Template Site
- Difference between list() and dict() with generators
- How can I serialize a numpy array while preserving matrix dimensions?
- Protractor did not run properly when using browser.wait, msg: "Wait timed out after XXXms"
- Why is my program adding int as string (4+7 = 47)?
- store numpy array in mysql
- how to omit the less frequent words from a dictionary in python?
- Update a text file with ( new words+ \n ) after the words is appended into a list
Related Questions in MEMBER-HIDING
- new thread blocks main thread
- Extracting viewCount & SubscriberCount from YouTube API V3 for a given channel, where channelID does not equal userID
- Display images on Django Template Site
- Difference between list() and dict() with generators
- How can I serialize a numpy array while preserving matrix dimensions?
- Protractor did not run properly when using browser.wait, msg: "Wait timed out after XXXms"
- Why is my program adding int as string (4+7 = 47)?
- store numpy array in mysql
- how to omit the less frequent words from a dictionary in python?
- Update a text file with ( new words+ \n ) after the words is appended into a list
Popular Questions
- How do I undo the most recent local commits in Git?
- How can I remove a specific item from an array in JavaScript?
- How do I delete a Git branch locally and remotely?
- Find all files containing a specific text (string) on Linux?
- How do I revert a Git repository to a previous commit?
- How do I create an HTML button that acts like a link?
- How do I check out a remote Git branch?
- How do I force "git pull" to overwrite local files?
- How do I list all files of a directory?
- How to check whether a string contains a substring in JavaScript?
- How do I redirect to another webpage?
- How can I iterate over rows in a Pandas DataFrame?
- How do I convert a String to an int in Java?
- Does Python have a string 'contains' substring method?
- How do I check if a string contains a specific word?
Popular Tags
Trending Questions
- UIImageView Frame Doesn't Reflect Constraints
- Is it possible to use adb commands to click on a view by finding its ID?
- How to create a new web character symbol recognizable by html/javascript?
- Why isn't my CSS3 animation smooth in Google Chrome (but very smooth on other browsers)?
- Heap Gives Page Fault
- Connect ffmpeg to Visual Studio 2008
- Both Object- and ValueAnimator jumps when Duration is set above API LvL 24
- How to avoid default initialization of objects in std::vector?
- second argument of the command line arguments in a format other than char** argv or char* argv[]
- How to improve efficiency of algorithm which generates next lexicographic permutation?
- Navigating to the another actvity app getting crash in android
- How to read the particular message format in android and store in sqlite database?
- Resetting inventory status after order is cancelled
- Efficiently compute powers of X in SSE/AVX
- Insert into an external database using ajax and php : POST 500 (Internal Server Error)
In short
This is not legal at all. Depending of what's in the private part that is committed, it might work on some implementations, but it might very well fail at the first change or new release of the compiler. Just don't. There are better ways to achieve the intended objectives.
Some more explanations
Why it's not legal?
It's the One Definition Rule (ODR). It's defined in the standard, in a long section
[basic.def.odr]
. In summary, it is possible to have multiple definition of the same class in different compilation units (e.g. your code, and the library's code), but only if it's exactly the same definition. This requires that it's exactly the same sequence of tokens that are used for the two definitions, which is clearly not the case if you leave out the private members. (Note that there are additional requirements as well, but the first one is already broken, so I short-circuit).Why does it work in practice in some cases even if not legal?
It's purely implementation dependent luck. I will not develop this topic, in order not to encourage dangerous behavior.
What alternatives
Just use the same definition of the class everywhere. Private members are private, so what's the risk of leaving them where they were ?
Ok, sometimes the definition of private members would require to disclose also private types, end as a chain reaction, much too much. In this case, you may think of: