For Serialization of Primitive Array, i'am wondering how to convert a Primitive[] to his corresponding byte[]. (ie an int[128] to a byte[512], or a ushort[] to a byte[]...) The destination can be a Memory Stream, a network message, a file, anything. The goal is performance (Serialization & Deserialization time), to be able to write with some streams a byte[] in one shot instead of loop'ing' through all values, or allocate using some converter.
Some already solution explored:
Regular Loop to write/read
//array = any int[];
myStreamWriter.WriteInt32(array.Length);
for(int i = 0; i < array.Length; ++i)
myStreamWriter.WriteInt32(array[i]);
This solution works for Serialization and Deserialization And is like 100 times faster than using Standard System.Runtime.Serialization combined with a BinaryFormater to Serialize/Deserialize a single int, or a couple of them.
But this solution becomes slower if array.Length contains more than 200/300 values (for Int32).
Cast?
Seems C# can't directly cast a Int[] to a byte[], or a bool[] to a byte[].
BitConverter.Getbytes()
This solution works, but it allocates a new byte[] at each call of the loop through my int[]. Performances are of course horrible
Marshal.Copy
Yup, this solution works too, but same problem as previous BitConverter one.
C++ hack
Because direct cast is not allowed in C#, i tryed some C++ hack after seeing into memory that array length is stored 4 bytes before array data starts
ARRAYCAST_API void Cast(int* input, unsigned char** output)
{
// get the address of the input (this is a pointer to the data)
int* count = input;
// the size of the buffer is located just before the data (4 bytes before as this is an int)
count--;
// multiply the number of elements by 4 as an int is 4 bytes
*count = *count * 4;
// set the address of the byte array
*output = (unsigned char*)(input);
}
and the C# that call:
byte[] arrayB = null;
int[] arrayI = new int[128];
for (int i = 0; i < 128; ++i)
arrayI[i] = i;
// delegate call
fptr(arrayI, out arrayB);
I successfully retrieve my int[128] into C++, switch the array length, and affecting the right adress to my 'output' var, but C# is only retrieving a byte[1] as return. It seems that i can't hack a managed variable like that so easily.
So i really start to think that all theses casts i want to achieve are just impossible in C# (int[] -> byte[], bool[] -> byte[], double[] -> byte[]...) without Allocating/copying...
What am-i missing?
How about using
Buffer.BlockCopy
?Note that
BlockCopy
is still allocating/copying behind the scenes. I'm fairly sure that this is unavoidable in managed code, andBlockCopy
is probably about as good as it gets for this.