Error: Immutable value passed on reduce function

3.5k views Asked by At

I'm trying to do the following code that transforms an array of tuples into a dictionary but I'm receiving a compile error saying:

Immutable value of type '[String : String]' only has mutating members named 'updateValue'

var array = [("key0", "value0"), ("key1", "value1")]
var initial = [String: String]()
var final = array.reduce(initial) { (dictionary, tuple) in
    dictionary.updateValue(tuple.0, forKey: tuple.1)
    return dictionary
}

Why is that if initial was declared as var? Does it have to do with @noescape on reduce's signature?

func reduce<U>(initial: U, combine: @noescape (U, T) -> U) -> U
3

There are 3 answers

5
Antonio On BEST ANSWER

You can simply make the dictionary parameter mutable by preceding it with var:

var final = array.reduce(initial) { (var dictionary, tuple) in
                                     ^^^

Note however that using reduce a new dictionary is created at each iteration, making the algorithm very inefficient. You might want to consider using a traditional foreach loop

0
Igor On

On Swift 3:

var final = array.reduce(initial) { (dictionary, tuple) -> [String: String] in
    var mutableDictionary = dictionary
    //.... make changes with mutableDictionary
    return mutableDictionary
}
0
mxcl On

Swift 4 has a new variant:

var array = [("key0", "value0"), ("key1", "value1")]
var initial = [String: String]()
var final = array.reduce(into: initial) { dictionary, tuple in
    dictionary[tuple.0] = tuple.1
}

Which could be expressed:

var array = [("key0", "value0"), ("key1", "value1")]
let final: [String: String] = array.reduce(into: [:]){ $0[$1.0] = $1.1 }